Halloween Sugar Cookies

Halloween Sugar Cookies
October 29, 2012 Alison Faulkner

As you know, I LOVE making sugar cookies. I have some old stand-bys when it comes to making my cookies, but I’m always trying to perfect my craft. I’ve been super excited to try the recipes in this new book that I bought: Decorating Cookies by Bridget Edwards. And I finally got the chance!

Overall I really like her royal icing recipe, it uses meringue powder, and though I usually like to use egg whites (as I show in my video here) when I’m making cookies to take to lots of people I feel better using meringue powder just to be safe. When I’m using egg whites from our chickens I don’t worry, but we don’t get as many eggs in the winter. The icing doesn’t taste as good as my usual recipe (it’s in the video), but I think next time I’ll add some lemon juice and give it the zing that I like. The consistency, however, is AMAZING. Absolutely picture perfect.

I tried the Almond Sugar Cookie recipe and it was good, but not as soft as my usual cookie. This could be due to elevation, but I will probably use my old cookie recipe with the new icing recipe in the future. I will share my recipe with you soon!

I think sometimes it can be hard to envision the end result of a sugar cookie when you look at the cookie cutter, so I thought I’d show what the cookie cutters looked like in case you were curious. I bought this set last year at Joann, but it’s here too.

Also! I had the hardest time coming up with good saying for my tombstones! I finally found some good slightly funny ones online, and then saw some around the neighborhood (in yards) and these are what I came up with. I think you want decorative tombstone phrases to be fun and slightly twisted but not full-on grotesque, right?

All in all I love making sugar cookies so much and I don’t like eating them so it works out nicely.

Plus I have the cutest baking assistant ever. She might not be super helpful but she’s really good at raw cookie dough.

I hope you have a very spooky Halloween! I think I seriously might make one more batch of cookies…I have a problem. But if you want to see other ones I’ve done, here are some: Edible Gem Necklace Cookies, Christmas Cookies, and I still need to do a post on Gigi’s Pony cookies! And what I realized when I went to list all of my cookies is that I hardly ever get finished pictures of them on the blog (yet another reason you should follow me on instagram) but I’m seriously going to rectify this ASAP.

I love your guts.


  1. Meg in Progress 5 years ago

    That picture of Ginger is worth the price of admission. Plus 100 million dollars.

  2. Olivia 5 years ago

    Ingrid or missglamorazzi brought me here! I love the spider cookies!

  3. Jessica 5 years ago

    Between that face Ginger is making and the deliciousness of the cookies… let’s just say I wish I was at your house right now. So cute!

  4. Hannah 4 years ago

    Love these! Pinned them!

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *